Missing, Presumed vs The Ice Beneath Her 

I felt like spicing it up by reading two thrillers at the same time and comparing them. I picked The Ice Beneath Her (IBH) by Camille Grebe; a Swedish author, and a British thriller by Susie Steiner called Missing Presumed (MP). So who will win? The translated or the traditional?

The Beginning Chapter

One of the most important chapters of a book – it needs to set the scene, spark imagination and leave you wanting to read on. Both authors chose to start from the eye of a detective on the case and show the reader what they get up to prior to being called to the scene. Peter in IBH is visiting his mother’s grave whilst Manon in MP is enduring a rather disastrous date. Steiner’s opening pages were light hearted and made you warm to a key character, whereas Grebe chose to use short jumpy sentences with a darker feel. Which gripped me more? IBH won this category.

The Victim

24 year old, Edith Hind is missing from her flat in MP and the police are hot on the case to find her before it turns into a murder investigation. There’s a 25 year old girl found beheaded in Jesper Orre’s mansion and it’s unclear who it is in IBH. One victim identified, one not; which style did I prefer? Either, it’s a draw on this one.

The Page Turner Capability

The books are a similar length so in theory the test is which did I read quicker. I divulged IBH in less than two days whereas MP took me four days – this was due to the slow parts of the books causing my mind to wonder and I always close a book at this point. The more moments my mind wonders, the slower the pages get turned…. IBH won this round.

The Style

Both books chose to use multiple character view points with the chapter headings providing an indication of whose eyes we were looking through. I LOVE this style. It’s perfect for a police case. There was however one significant difference, IBH chose to include a view point from a character directly involved in the crime whereas MP only utilised the detectives and the victim’s relatives perspectives….up until the very last chapters.

One direct and one indirect, the indirect approach utilised the police detectives’ own life problems to distract from the crime which meant you weren’t guessing who did it?! as much, whereas the direct approach in IBH meant you understood the events leading up to the crime.

The winner? Tricky I prefer the direct style but it only works if you’ve got a complex plot, it worked in Daisy in Chains but not so well in IBH.

The Suspects

Who had the bigger range of suspects? Definitely MP. It could have been anyone: the boyfriend, the best friend, the father, the local criminal and even Manon’s new boyfriend seems a bit shifty and far too interested in the case… and that’s me just thinking off the top of my head – this book pointed the finger in numerous directions! Whereas IBH had a rather limited selection of characters and I cottoned on pretty quickly who it was because of this. MP wins.

Conclusion

Which did I prefer? I can’t decide! I loved the bluntness and jumpiness of IBH but there wasn’t enough plot twists which meant I’d figured out the plot before I’d entered the last 150 pages. MP was full of plot twists and kept me guessing up until the last 30 pages, the difficulty I had with this book – there were too many slow chapters which focused on the lives of the detectives instead of the case…which I found a little dull.

Until next time, Chloé x

Advertisements

4 Comments

Add yours →

  1. Interesting post. I like how you have reviewed the two books. I haven’t read ICH but I hope to do so soon. MP wasn’t for e though due to the slow pacing, detailed description of detective’s personal lives and the many characters and POVs. I liked the list of suspects though.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I wish I loved reading as much as you!! Any recommendations for beginners as I’ve never really got to read many books. Enjoy the rest of your Sunday, Kisses from London! Dominica.
    http://www.its-dominica.blogspot.co.uk

    Like

  3. wow i love your book reviews your blog is amazing

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: